Behind the Research #4
Behind the Research #4
When most people think about leadership, they think about positive qualities—vision, courage, confidence, integrity. But leadership is not inherently good. Bad leadership is surprisingly common, and its consequences can be severe: miserable employees, damaged teams, poor decisions, and underperforming organizations.
Over the past 20 years, research on the dark side of leadership has produced a compelling body of practical insights about why otherwise talented and successful people can become ineffective or destructive leaders. This article distills that research into five major lessons:
1. How to identify a leader’s dark side: The personality tendencies that can become exaggerated and counterproductive, especially under stress.
2. Why standing out is not the same as leading well: Why the people who rise fastest are not necessarily the people who build the highest-performing teams.
3. Why organizations are so easily dazzled by charisma: How confidence, vision, and personal magnetism can become arrogance, recklessness, and self-promotion.
4. Why absentee leadership is an overlooked but pervasive problem: Leaders who occupy the role but fail to provide direction, accountability, feedback, or active leadership. 5. Why the real test of leadership is not winning inside the organization, but helping the organization win outside it: The crucial distinction between competition for status within groups and competition between groups.
Robert B. Kaiser, co-author of Twenty Years on the Dark Side: Six Lessons About Bad Leadership joins Rachel Boehm, Ph.D., to drill into the findings and perspectives in the piece. They also discuss what business leaders, consulting psychologists, and others in the leadership and organizational development space should do about them.
Mainstream leadership research has suffered from a positivity bias by focusing on the desirable attributes of leaders to the neglect of the unpleasant reality that many leaders behave badly and cause great harm. This article enhances leader selection and leader development by summarizing six lessons learned in the 20 years since Robert and Joyce Hogan introduced the concept of the dark side of personality and leadership.